EAC-PM member Sanjeev Sanyal suggests ending population control policies amid falling fertility
India should end population control policies as fertility rates have sharply dropped. A government advisor suggests realigning family planning with demographic changes. Incentives for sterilizations and two-child norms should be repealed immediately. Fertility reduction language must be removed from all policy frameworks. Family planning for health and personal choice remains important.
360° Perspective Analysis
Deep-dive into Geography, Polity, Economy, History, Environment & Social dimensions — AI-powered, on-demand
Context
A working paper titled 'The Ghost of Population Past,' co-authored by Sanjeev Sanyal, a member of the (EAC-PM), advocates for ending India's population control policies due to falling fertility rates. The paper highlights that India's Total Fertility Rate (TFR) has dropped to 1.9 (below the replacement level of 2.1) and suggests repealing incentives linked to sterilization and two-child norms to avoid falling into a 'low-fertility trap' like some developed nations.
UPSC Perspectives
Social
The core of this issue lies in India's shifting demographics. For decades, India's burgeoning population was viewed as a primary hurdle to development, leading to aggressive population control measures, including the . The focus was on achieving population stabilization by bringing the Total Fertility Rate (TFR)—the average number of children born to a woman over her lifetime—down to the replacement level of 2.1. However, the EAC-PM paper argues that this goal has not only been met but surpassed, with the national TFR currently at 1.9. The paper warns against the dangers of a 'low-fertility trap,' a scenario observed in countries like Japan and many in Europe, where TFR drops significantly below replacement level, leading to an aging population and a shrinking workforce. The recommendation to dismantle policies enforcing the two-child norm and financial incentives for sterilization reflects a critical shift from population control to population management, emphasizing family planning for health and spacing rather than absolute reduction. For UPSC Mains (GS Paper 1), you should analyze the long-term social implications of sub-replacement fertility, including the potential challenges of an aging demographic and the changing structure of the Indian family.
Governance
From a governance perspective, the EAC-PM paper calls for a fundamental overhaul of state policies related to family planning. Historically, the Indian state has employed a mix of incentives and disincentives to curb population growth. These included direct benefit transfers for sterilization, (ASHA) incentives for limiting family size, and even disqualifications for local body elections for individuals with more than two children in certain states. The working paper argues that continuing these policies is counterproductive given the new demographic reality. It explicitly recommends discontinuing state-sponsored events like 'Vasectomy Fortnight' and removing population stabilization language from policy frameworks. This signifies a move away from coercive or heavily incentivized population control methods towards a rights-based approach to reproductive health. For GS Paper 2, candidates must evaluate the efficacy and ethical dimensions of past population control policies and the rationale for transitioning towards policies that respect reproductive autonomy while addressing emerging demographic challenges.
Economic
The economic implications of this demographic shift are profound. India has long touted its demographic dividend—the economic growth potential that results from a shift in a population's age structure, specifically when the share of the working-age population (15-64 years) is larger than the non-working-age share. However, as the TFR falls below replacement level, the window of this demographic dividend begins to close. The EAC-PM's concern about falling into a 'low-fertility trap' is essentially an economic concern: a shrinking workforce and a growing dependent elderly population can severely strain public finances, healthcare systems, and overall economic productivity. If India's TFR continues to decline steeply (currently at 1.6 excluding Bihar and Uttar Pradesh, comparable to the US and Northern Europe), the focus must rapidly shift from job creation for a young population to managing an aging workforce, increasing labor productivity, and reforming pension and social security systems. In GS Paper 3, this topic is crucial for understanding the interplay between demographic trends, human capital formation, and long-term economic planning.